/ Insights/ Commentary/ Adoption

All you can eat.

Martin Lulham
The word BUFFET? set in heavy outlined capitals, with a thick red horizontal line running across the frame behind the letters.

Four days. That's how long it took.

Last Thursday I wrote Hooked., about the AI tools we've all come to rely on. My argument was that the price probably isn't the thing to fear. The quieter risk is the tool changing under your feet: the assistant that "tells you you've hit your limit by lunchtime".

By the weekend, that had happened to a lot of people.

Subscribers to Grok Bot, the AI assistant from Elon Musk's xAI, started finding their weekly allowance gone days early. One user posted that they'd hit 100 per cent with four days still to go before it reset. Another said their usage meter jumped from 44 to 87 per cent in 24 minutes. On Cursor's forums, where many Grok Bot users manage their accounts, people described stepping away at 60 per cent and coming back to 100, with nothing running in between.

When someone asked Musk on X whether xAI would reset everyone's allowance, his reply was short. "The cost of serving Grok Bot was unsustainably high relative to revenue," he wrote.

It wasn't a yes.

What actually happened

There were two things going on, and the early reporting mixed them up.

The first was a fault. Grok's official account said the usage dashboard had briefly shown readings that were too high for many people, and that this was fixed and hadn't affected anyone's actual usage. That explains some of the strangest screenshots.

The second was deliberate. The same account said allowances had been adjusted because the service cost so much to run. According to AFP's report, xAI hasn't said by how much, hasn't offered a reset, and hasn't announced any change to prices. As some observers pointed out, Musk's past tense, "was", suggests the decision has already been made.

So people paying the same money got noticeably less this week than last, and found out by running out.

Why an assistant that does things is different

It helps to know what Grok Bot is. It isn't a chatbot you ask a question and get an answer from. It's what the industry calls an agent: you give it a job, and it goes off and does it, step by step, for as long as it takes. It might search the web, write and test some code, and come back to you hours later.

That's the appeal. It's also the problem.

Think of a buffet. A normal chatbot conversation is like a diner who goes up once, has a plate of food and leaves. An agent is a diner who stays all day, with a friend going back for more while they sleep. At a flat price per head, the restaurant can afford a few of those. When they're most of the room, the plates start getting smaller.

That's what the plans look like. Under the X Subscription, launched last month, Grok Bot comes with Premium at $30 a month, Super at $100 and Ultra at $200. Each gives you a weekly allowance, and on the new plans it's one pool shared across Grok, Grok Bot and Cursor. Heavy agent work eats it much faster than chat.

None of this is unique to xAI, and it would be unfair to suggest it was. Last summer Anthropic introduced weekly limits on its Claude plans for the same reason: some subscribers were running its coding tool around the clock. M-Tech builds on Claude, so I noticed. Every company selling agents at a flat monthly price is doing the same sums.

The fair objection

There's a decent argument that Musk did the honest thing.

A provider that admits a service costs more than it earns, and corrects it, is in better shape than one that quietly loses money until it can't. The heaviest users were getting an extraordinary deal, and a deal like that was never going to last. Even after the cut, $30 a month for an assistant that can do hours of work is cheap by any normal measure.

I agree with most of that. The cut itself doesn't bother me much.

What bothers me is that nobody could see it coming, and nobody can measure it now.

Look at how the allowances are described. Premium gets "4x" the usage of the cheapest plan, Super "15x" and Ultra "50x". Four times what? None of these companies tells you how much a single unit is, or how much of it a given task uses. It's a mobile contract promising four times the data without ever mentioning gigabytes. That's how a provider can give you a much less generous deal on a Saturday without changing a single number on the pricing page.

Users noticed. Some asked xAI for something very simple: a way to see how much of the week each task had used. Investor Martin Casado asked whether a cheaper model could do the basic work, since most of what he used it for was simple. Both are good questions. Neither has had an answer yet.

If you've built anything on one of these

For most people, a smaller allowance is an annoyance. You wait until Monday, or you use something else.

It's different if a business process now depends on it. If an agent drafts your quotes, chases your invoices or does a job a person used to do, a weekly allowance isn't a capacity plan. It's a promotion, and promotions change.

A few things I'd do:

  1. Find out what happens at 100 per cent. Does the work stop, or does it carry on and bill you? Grok Bot users have complained for months of no warning before their usage spills into paid on-demand. Either answer is fine as long as you know which one you've got.
  2. Don't run business-critical work on a personal plan. Consumer allowances are built for individuals and adjusted for the average. Business and pay-as-you-go plans publish a price per unit. It's less exciting, and it's predictable.
  3. Watch the meter for a few weeks. If your provider shows usage, note how much a normal week takes. You'll then spot a change before it stops you.
  4. Keep a second option warm. As I said last week, run one everyday task through a different tool now and then, so a bad week isn't also your first try.

Close

"All you can eat" always meant "until we say otherwise". That's fine, as long as you can see the plate getting smaller.

Right now, you can't. Until the providers say what a week's allowance actually buys, plan as if it might halve without warning, because this weekend it more or less did.

/ Start a conversation

Let's talk about what you're trying to build.

Book a discovery session and we'll walk through the workflow, the systems and the shape of the solution.